Skip to content
How to Choose an SEO Agency

How to choose an SEO agency: hire a genuine SEO expert, not a sales pitch

Most SEO agencies sound similar on a first call. Here's how to check reviews properly, spot red flags, and use free tools to verify what an agency tells you — before you sign anything, whether that's us or someone else.

Reviewswhere to actually check them
Free toolsto verify claims yourself
Red flagsworth walking away from
Real questionsto ask on the first call
Checking SEO Company Reviews

Where reviews are actually harder to fake

Testimonials on an agency's own website are the easiest thing to curate. These sources take more effort to game.

Google Business Profile

Read the actual review text, not just the star average — look for specific, detailed feedback rather than generic five-star comments.

Clutch & B2B Directories

Independent platforms that verify reviewers are real clients, with more detail than a typical testimonial.

Direct References

Ask to speak to a current client in a similar industry — a confident agency won't hesitate to offer one.

Free SEO Tools South Africa

Tools to verify what an agency tells you

You don't need to be technical to spot-check these — most take under five minutes.

Google Search Console

Free and connects directly to your site — shows your actual indexing status and search performance, independent of any agency's report.

Google PageSpeed Insights

Verify any claim about site speed improvements with a free, direct test.

Google Rich Results Test

Confirms whether schema markup an agency says it implemented is actually valid and live on your pages.

Red Flags

Signs worth walking away from

A guaranteed exact ranking position, no audit before a proposal, vague answers about what work is actually being done month to month, and reporting that only shows rankings with no connection to traffic or leads — any one of these is worth a harder look before you commit.

Ask Us These Questions Too
Questions Worth Asking

What to ask on the first call

These questions separate a considered proposal from a generic sales pitch.

AskWeak AnswerStrong Answer
"What's your audit process?"No mention of one, or a quote before looking at your site.A described process with a clear list of what's checked.
"Can I see example content?"Ranking screenshots only.Real page examples and what changed after the work.
"How does reporting work?"A generic monthly PDF.Reporting tied to traffic quality and enquiries, not just position.
"What if it's not working after 3 months?"Deflection or a longer contract push.A clear explanation of how strategy gets reassessed.
Before you hire

How to hire an SEO company without regretting it

A short checklist for choosing the best SEO agency for your business, and spotting a real SEO expert.

Seven questions before you hire an SEO company

  1. Can I see your prices in writing?
  2. What exactly will you do each month?
  3. Who does the work, and can I talk to them?
  4. How do you build links?
  5. Who owns my website, Search Console, Analytics and Google Business Profile?
  6. What does a monthly report look like?
  7. What is the notice period?

What makes the best SEO agency for you

The best SEO agency isn’t the one with the most awards or the biggest client logos. It’s the one that understands your market, explains its plan clearly and reports on leads, not just rankings. Ask for a sample audit, check the agency’s own Google rankings, and read reviews from businesses like yours.

How to spot a genuine SEO expert

A genuine SEO expert explains things in plain language, gives specific findings about your pages, and is honest about timelines. You can check their claims yourself with our free SERP snippet preview, content analyzer and SEO audit guide.

How we compare

HeftySEO vs a typical SEO company in South Africa

Before you sign with any SEO company or SEO agency, put these questions to them. Here is how we answer each one.

Question to askWhat you often getWhat you get from HeftySEO
Can I see your prices before a sales call?"Contact us for a quote" or a "view prices" button that leads to a formPublished SEO packages from R3,000 a month, with every inclusion listed
What do you do each month?A vague "ongoing optimisation" line itemA written list of completed work in every monthly report
How do you measure success?Traffic and keyword counts, often for terms nobody buys fromOrganic calls, forms and Google Maps actions, alongside rankings
How do you build links?Bulk directory or private-network links that can trigger a penaltyWhite hat only: no bought links, no PBNs, no guaranteed rankings
Who owns my accounts?The agency, which makes leaving painfulYou do: website, Search Console, Analytics and Google Business Profile stay in your name
Do you offer more than one service?Ads, social, video and web design bundled into one retainer, with SEO as a small sliceSEO is the whole job, from audits to local SEO and ecommerce SEO
Can I check your work myself?RarelyYes, with our free SEO tools and plain-English SEO guides
More questions

More questions we get asked

What are red flags when hiring an SEO agency?

Guaranteed rankings, secret methods, cheap bulk backlinks, no access to your own accounts, long lock-in contracts and reports without leads or traffic.

What should I ask an SEO company before hiring?

Ask what work they will do each month, how they measure success, who does the work, how they build links, who owns the accounts and what notice period applies.

How do I know if my SEO agency is doing a good job?

Organic impressions, clicks and leads should trend upward over 6 to 12 months, and you should receive clear reports showing the work done.

Looking for more? Browse our free SEO guides.

FAQ

Choosing an agency — common questions

Straight answers to help you evaluate any SEO agency, not just us.

Google Business Profile reviews, Clutch and independent B2B review platforms are harder to fake than testimonials on an agency's own website. Cross-check a few sources.

Google Search Console and Analytics for your own data, PageSpeed Insights for speed claims, and the Rich Results Test to verify schema markup.

What their audit process looks like, for examples of unique content (not just rankings), how reporting ties to leads, and what happens if it isn't working after a few months.

A guaranteed ranking position, no audit before a proposal, vague answers about actual work, and reporting that only shows rankings with no link to traffic or leads.
Put Us to the Test

Ask us these exact questions

Use the checklist above on us. Send your site and we will show you our audit process directly, rather than asking you to take our word for it.

Audit before proposal — always
Real examples shown, not just claims
No guaranteed-ranking promises — ever
108 Southward Dr, Clayville, Midrand, 1632
WhatsApp: +27 87 255 3273